D21 terrace vs D21 condo: 10-year total return comparison
- Terrace house
- $3,200,000 | Appreciation: 3.5% p.a. | Rent: $6,500/month
- Condo
- $1,800,000 | Appreciation: 3.0% p.a. | Rent: $4,200/month
- Holding period
- 10 years
- Financing
- Both at 75% LTV, 3.5% interest, 25yr tenure
- Terrace Year 10 value
- $4,524,000 (+$1,324,000 capital gain)
- Condo Year 10 value
- $2,419,000 (+$619,000 capital gain)
- Terrace net rental income (10yr)
- $588,000 (gross) − maintenance − tax
- Condo net rental income (10yr)
- $453,600 (gross) − MCST − tax
How to read this: The terrace produces $1,324,000 in capital gain vs the condo's $619,000 — $705,000 more in absolute appreciation. But the terrace required $1,400,000 more in initial equity (25% of $3.2M vs $450K for condo). On a return-on-equity basis, the condo generates a higher percentage return on the smaller equity deployed. The terrace wins on absolute dollar return; the condo wins on capital efficiency. The correct comparison for an investor choosing between the two depends on their total capital: i...